Top 12 Girls – Your Favorites?
The Top 12 Girls performed live for the first time tonite, also singing songs from the 60’s as the Top 12 guys did last night. I absolutely love Amanda Overmyer, a true rocker girl. While I didn’t think any of the others were exceptionally great, a few did stand out to me, including Brooke White, Ramiele Malubay, Syesha Mercado, and possibly Carly Smithson, although she definitely wasn’t as good as I expected her to be after all the hype about the “Irish Girl”. I think Syesha sounded pretty good, but she seems a little overconfident. Randy and Paula both loved, loved, loved Carly, while Simon didn’t “get” her performance. All three judges loved Amanda, Syesha, and Ramiele. Except for Amanda, I enjoyed the guy’s performances last night far more than the girl’s tonite.
Tomorrow night on the first results show (Fox-8pm EST), two guys and two girls will be voted out.
Individual photos above from American Idol Top 24